From Cory Doctorow@Plurastic.In XKCD 2295, "Garbage Math," Randall Munroe does a stellar job elucidating the uncertainty plaguing our ability to estimate when lockdown will end.
https://xkcd.com/2295/
The thing is, several key variables are unknown and attempts to estimate them produce "garbage numbers." These include:
What percentage of people have covid-19 antibodies
What percentage of people who have covid-19 antibodies are immune to the disease, and for how long
When we will develop a vaccine for covid-19
How long production of the vaccine will take after it is developed
When we will discover effective therapeutics for covid-19
How long it will take to ramp up their production
These variables produce a combinatorial explosion of scenarios for when the lockdown will end, and how long after that the crisis will pass. These scenarios are the reason we have a range of "estimates" – they're not estimates, they're scenarios.
If a and b, then x more weeks. If a, b and c, then y more weeks. If a and c, etc, etc.
These kinds of scenarios are a lot more common than predictions, but scenarios are usually presented (by governments, press and science communicators) as predictions.
In part, that's because our public discourse has little room for scenarios – but also, that's partly why our public discourse has little room for scenarios.
Showing posts with label Cory Doctorow. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cory Doctorow. Show all posts
29 Apr 2020
Garbage Math
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
